This N172 Old Judge of Tim Keefe pictures him from the front, both hands on the ball, with the caption reading “TIM KEEFE, P. N.Y’s.”. PSA has assigned a grade of EX 5 to this card and their Population Report shows six other Old Judge Tim Keefe cards have also received the same grade. However, they fail to differentiate on over 10 different varieties so their true population on this card could be somewhat inaccurate.